Coffee = caffeine. Caffeine = energy boost.
But not everyone who drinks coffee likes the effect of caffeine on their day-to-day existence or simply due to health reasons are unable to consume.
These people luckily have an option in the form of decaffeinated coffee. But what does this mean? And how do they remove caffeine from coffee?
Let’s start off by confirmed that, yes, coffee does contain a good amount of caffeine, but contrary to what you thought coffee actually has less caffeine that tea.
But that’s not exactly correct, yes, tea has more caffeine in an unbrewed dry leaf form on average. But coffee has more in a brewed form.
On average a cup of tea provides 40mg vs 105mg in the average cup of drip coffee, so just over 2 ¼ cups of tea equal the caffeine boost of an average cup of coffee.
Granted this doesn’t take into account the beans, length of brew time and a few other key factors, it’s at least a solid indication of the differences between the two hot drinks.
So if we have to get rid of this theoretical average of 105mg per cup of drip coffee, how are we going to go about it?
Removing caffeine from coffee
Unfortunately, there isn’t one ‘catch-all’ process that is used on every single bean.
Instead, we have a series of processes that change based upon the continental regulations, type of bean used and a few other minor factors.
But it’s all worth it for those that want to enjoy their coffee without the associated stimulation effect.
There are four main methods used to remove the caffeine from coffee used today.
To make things a little more simple, these can be categorised via the usage of solvents.
|Solvent-based processes||Non-solvent based processes|
Any solvent based process are those where a chemical solvent is used to remove caffeine from the coffee bean, commonly these tend to be methylene chloride or ethyl acetate.
The direct method sees the beans soaked directly in the solvent to remove the caffeine.
Whereas indirect solvent processing the caffeine laden water is transferred to separate tank and treated with a solvent.
This means that the solvent itself never actually touches the beans.
Any solvents used in the process of removing caffeine are harmless, with beans being washed thoroughly to remove any traces left over for added peace of mind.
- Beans are soaked in water just shy of boiling for several hours, this extracts the caffeine but can also remove some of the oil and flavours from the coffee beans.
- The water gets separated and moved to another tank, it’s here that the beans are washed again for about 10 hours with either methylene chloride or ethyl acetate.
- This solvent bonds with the caffeine molecules and the mixture left is heated to evaporate the solvent and caffeine.
- Coffee beans are then reintroduced to the water mixture to absorb the oils and flavours previously extracted.
- The coffee beans are steamed for around 30 minutes, this opens the coffee bean pores to make them more receptive to the addition of a solvent.
- Once this steaming process is complete, the coffee beans are rinsed repeatedly with methylene chloride or ethyl acetate.
Sometimes this method is referred to as ‘The Natural Decaffeination Method’ or the ‘Ethyl Acetate Method’.
Swiss Water Process
One of the oldest decaffeination processes in usage today, this pioneering method was first used in Switzerland in 1933.
But it wasn’t until 1979 that it was truly utilised by a company called Coffex.
At the end of the 1970s and early 1980s it was the only decaffeination method that was not using solvents to remove caffeine.
The popularity of the Swiss Water Process is due to the usage of the method in the speciality coffee sector.
Unlike the aforementioned solvent using processes, the Swiss Water Process uses no chemicals at all.
So if no solvents are used, how do they extract the caffeine? Well, here’s how:
- Firstly the coffee beans are soaked in very hot water to dissolve the caffeine.
- This water is then drawn off and passed through an activated charcoal filter. The filter is porous, but only catches the larger caffeine molecules and lets the smaller oil and resulting flavour molecules pass straight through.
- That leaves us with beans that have no caffeine and almost zero flavour in one tank, and the caffeine-free flavour-packed water (known as ‘Green Coffee Extract’) in another tank.
- The flavourless caffeine-free beans are discarded, but the flavour rich water is reused to remove the caffeine from a fresh batch of coffee beans.
- So with this water already being saturated with flavour, the flavour can’t dissolve in this fresh batch of beans, meaning only the caffeine moves from the coffee beans into the water.
- This results in decaffeination without a major loss of flavour.
Here’s a detailed video explaining the process in action:
Carbon Dioxide Process
The CO2 Process is sometimes referred to as the Liquid Carbon Dioxide method and Supercritical Carbon Dioxide method.
One of the most recent innovations in decaffeinated coffee, this process was developed by Kurt Zosel, a scientist a the Max Plank Institute.
By using liquid carbon dioxide (CO2) instead of a solvent, it can actively target the caffeine molecules and nothing else.
How it works:
- Water soaked beans are placed in a stainless steel container or extraction vessel.
- The extractor is then sealed and liquid CO2 is forced into the coffee at intense high pressure to extract the caffeine.
- Liquid CO2 acts as a ‘solvent’ by drawing the caffeine within the coffee beans without detriment to the flavour and oil molecules within the bean.
- Full of caffeine, this CO2 liquid is transferred to another container called the absorption chamber.
- The pressure is released, leaving the liquid CO2 to return to it’s gaseous state, leaving just the caffeine behind.
- Now free of caffeine again, the CO2 gas is pumped back into a pressurised container for usage again.
A high-cost method, this is mainly used in mass quantities of coffee, mainly those found on supermarket shelves.
The Carbon Dioxide Process is growing in popularity as any potential long-term effects of using solvents is completely negated, meaning better tasting coffee that is completely decaffeinated.
But why is it so difficult to make good quality decaf coffee?
Let’s be 100% completely honest with you as coffee roasters and sellers of coffee, decaffeinated coffee is really hard to make well.
The major problem is that the process of removing the caffeine from coffee beans without doing any damage at all or having an effect on the flavour and quality is still not perfect.
Characteristics of the same bean, both decaffeinated and caffeinated will be markedly different.
Which is why you need to pick and choose your battles with decaf coffee.
From a roasting perspective, it’s just hard to roast compared to normal beans.
The colour of unroasted normal beans are green, unroasted decaffeinated beans are much more brown in appearance.
We lose more control over our refined roasting process as a result, and roasting these beans can be a little inconsistent with each batch.
A lower moisture content within the coffee bean also speeds up the roasting process as there is less moisture to absorb the heat.
This results in beans that roast darker and faster than our standard caffeine-rich coffee.
The good thing for our customers and especially those who buy our decaf options is that we are perfectionists.
We won’t settle for sub par decaffeinated coffee (and yes, we do drink it here) so that means instead of trying to offer a wide range of bang average decaf coffee, we instead refined our options to two blends that we can a) replicate consistently and b) provide a great coffee taste simply sans caffeine.
Therefore our decaf coffee range utilises a method that we are both familiar with, and have perfected to give you a great tasting decaffeinated coffee every single time.
Some of our micro-lot coffee is often decaffeinated via the Swiss Water Process, and we are experimenting with different methods to maintain our own flavour profile and signature taste.
If you’d like to learn more about our decaf coffee or have questions about our decaffeinated drinks options, then please call 01977 687 580 to begin your journey into a caffeine free coffee paradise.